The FM Extra

The FM Extra is a weekly free newspaper/shopper published Fridays in Moorhead, Minnesota by Extra Media Inc. and distributed throughout the surrounding area at grocery stores, convenience stores, and the like.

Contact Information

Email:	thefmextra@aol.com
Postal Address:	The FM Extra PO Box 1026 Moorhead MN 56561
Phone:	218-284-1288 or 877-674-2688
Fax:	218-284-1289
Web:	The FM Extra.com

Ancestry

The FM Extra was first published in May 2002 as the Clay County Extra, a supplement to the Clay County Union, a small paper from Ulen, Minnesota. The paper's original purpose, according to editor John Kolness, was "to bridge the gap between our rural readers and the businesses in Fargo and Moorhead..." In 2005, the name was changed to the FM Extra.

Opinion: Flawed Internet Integration

Unlike the Valley Midweek Marketplace, the FM Extra does provide content online, in the form of a PDF version of their paper and graphic 'screenshots' of each page. While Google is somewhat able to index PDF content, individual articles and pieces of content are not directly linkable, removing any possibility of bringing in referential traffic from blogs or building a Pagerank. In terms of organization, it removes the ability to organize or sort content in any form other than by publishing date, rather than being able to browse all of Soo Asheim's or Larry Gauper's articles without jumping from issue to issue. The internet excels at flexible organization, and distribution online via a PDF defeats this flexibility. The use of graphic images of each page to distribute content shows an enormous lack of understanding of the internet's accessibility. Advocates of disabled internet users unanimously object to encoding text in a graphic image, because it defeats accessibility features of web browsers that allow the blind (or otherwise reading-hindered) to partake in website content. Descriptive links, using the title of the column on that particular page, connect users from the front page to the specific pages, but the actual page linked to is described by its page number only -- a frustratingly un-internetty way to identify a webpage. Both a PDF download and individual graphic page devour an enormous amount of bandwidth compared to text, and no doubt the rural readers, the claimed core of the FM Extra's target market, are regularly frustrated by the length of time it takes to download even a single page of content over their slower dial-up connections.

This does, however, demonstrate that the editors of the FM Extra recognize the importance of having access to their paper on the internet, but lack the expertise to properly integrate the internet into their publishing process. The flat-form newspaper is still a vital method of community communication due to its persistence of form and transportability; the internet is vital in its ability to rearrange and select information according to a specific user's tastes. The FM Extra does the first well; the latter, not so much.

Recommendation: The FM Extra needs to consult someone who has the technical savvy to take the PDF content and convert it -- possibly automatically -- to a web-based format so that search engines, bloggers, and aggregators can access individual 'chunks' of content without having to download an entire issue or figure out how to interpret pixels. Bells and whistles like discussions, comments, or blogs are not as necessary as proper organization, such as a detailed search engine (native, not borrowing Google) to make content readily accessible to those desiring it. As the paper touts its worldwide reach, it will be of greater interest to advertisers if the online content was an actual draw for readers.